Guest Blog: Newton’s Third Law and Existential Climate Change
Prof. Geoffrey Lipman is founder of the SUNX –Strong Universal Network, it supports community climate resilience through Impact -Travel, (pro /cons measured and managed, green growth at the core and 2050 future proofed). Our X brand shows both the eXistential reality of climate change and the eXchange of innovation and learning through the SUN “Centres, Connections and Community” system.
He was Assistant Secretary General and Spokesperson of UNWTO, the World Tourism Organization and he is Chair of the Advisory Board of the Christel DeHaan Tourism & Travel Research Institute.
Whatever
combination of forces led to Donald Trump
becoming President of the United States - and for at least the next 4 years, control
of nearly a quarter of the global economy, with his finger on the nuclear
button - remains a frightening mystery to most of us. Now he has that control and
is showing his disruptive leadership style he would do well to remember Newton’s third law “To every action there is an equal and opposite reaction”.
Already
many of his Executive Order initiatives have begun to demonstrate this reality
- starting with his initial quasi ban on Muslims from 7 countries and the
instant, outrage, demonstrations, and court challenges. Or his “Day One - Repeal
Obamacare” followed by the realization that you can’t without a replacement and
that needs Congress to build as well as knock down. His “Great Wall of Mexico”
and Fix Sanctuary Cities mantra – both producing predictable defiance and
deepening opposition. And on and on….
And
you can’t play reality TV games by threatening to unilaterally impose tariffs
or border taxes in a fit of pique and overturn delicate trade arrangements
crafted to bring balanced benefits to
all parties. You do so at the peril of retaliation and adding hidden costs to
US consumers. Yes it would be putting America first for Apple to build i-phones
entirely in the USA – it would just make them prohibitively expensive, reduce
sales massively and put Chinese factories out of work. So, what then if China, already
stung by currency accusations, and threats to its one China policy, decides to encourage its travellers to shun the
USA. Chinese tourists are an important US export - the negative impact would pretty
soon hit the US economy “bigly.”
Donald
Trump is a man who is inclined to toss out an outrageous idea, “double-down” on
his positions while offering a glimmer of hope that he’ll change his mind,
based on his “Art of the Deal” tactics. What he doesn’t seem to get is that you
can’t bully or play legal games with sovereign state partners for long, the way
you did as a businessman with small companies, a pseudo university, and
loopholes in the tax code. Or unravel
decades of partnership obligations with a smart one liner, the stroke of a pen
and a barrage of 140 character tweets.
Most
importantly, Donald Trump would also do well to remember there is a real elephant
in the room - climate change - that it’s existential and it doesn’t
have a twitter account. He has already signalled his disdain for the Paris
Treaty and placed shackles on the Environment Protection Agency in his first
week in office, in addition to nominating a climate change sceptic as
Administrator. And at the same time opening dormant pipelines and pledging to
give big oil a new state supported lease of drilling life.
All
this, while the science and the experts make it clear that Sandy type storms,
Louisiana type floods, Kansas type tornados and California style droughts will
only get more intense, more frequent and more costly. And it will hit everyone,
everywhere - inside the US and with similar patterns around the world.
These realities won’t change
because Donald Trump threatens to tear up the one deal that every country on
earth supports as the best chance for a survivable future. It’s time to “walk-back” the thoughtless anti-Paris
rhetoric and get on board with the rest of humanity.
Thanks for this.
ReplyDeleteI fear that any optimism derives from applying Newton’s third law of motion: for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. Unfortunately that applies only in the field of physics; in the complex, human, system world the law is more like: for every action there is a reaction of unknown magnitude and in any direction.
Perhaps Newton’s three laws for systems motion should be:
1. A system will never be at rest or in a state of uniform process, episodic change will always happen, driven by internal and external forces.
2. The magnitude of system change is completely undetermined by the scale of the system or the forces acting on it.
3. For every action on (or in) a system there is a reaction of unknown magnitude and in any direction, usually the most unexpected.
I guess what I mean is: don't expect a reaction to Trumpism to be one that returns things to 'normal' there is no normal.
Ian, Schumacher Institute