Skip to main content

A guest blog from Jeb Brugmann: A Greek Tragedy in 6 Parts OR How northern Europe (also) avoids its systemic problems

1. IT STARTED AS A POLITICAL PROJECT, aimed at eliminating European nationalistic tendencies and ensconcing a single common market. All the parties involved were aware, if not also complicit, that the 'numbers' were being cooked to support the political project. To build Eurozone membership in the 1990s and early Aughts, creative national accounting was used to meet financial thresholds for entry (e.g.,3% deficit/GDP threshold). European statistical and financial institutions knew that the fiscal household in a number of countries was in poor condition, but chose to look the other way on Greece, Spain, Portugal and Italy. Germany and France themselves violated the 3% threshold in years leading up to the 2007+ global financial crisis (GFC). These facts are overlooked amidst today's theatre of self-righteous northern European finger-wagging towards Greece.

Meanwhile, the European financial institutions (and the IMF) have continued to cooked numbers to promote their failed austerity policies for Greece (see below).

The bail-out troika's unreality about the effectiveness of austerity politics

2. THE EUROZONE WAS BUILT UPON A FOUNDATION OF WILD WEST FINANCE. In the same era as the Euro project, the deregulated banking sectors of the U.S. and Europe became masters of high-risk/high-profit derivative instruments, involving shell games of risk transfer and the purposeful obfuscation of financial realities and integrity. A well known case in point is Goldman Sachs' 2001, 2.8 billion euro debt swap with Greece--which included a currency swap allowing Greece to reduce the level of debt reported to Eurostat. “The Goldman Sachs deal is a very sexy story between two sinners,” said Christoforis Sardelis, who oversaw the swap as head of Greece’s Public Debt Management Agency from 1999 through 2004. German and French banks went on to make major loans to the corrupted, clientilistic Greek governments of both the traditional right and left. They knew that Greece's finances were a shaky house of cards, but felt protected by the strength of the euro and the complicit support of northern European governments and European institutions. Then the financial crisis hit--due to the now famous collateralized debt obligation (CDO) derivatives of the U.S. housing market (which had fueled a housing market that was building 60% more housing than the growth in the number of actual U.S. households)--highlighting the fact: it's a systemic problem, not a single-nation problem...

governments and the European Union opted to bail out their risk-taking lenders instead of making them pay for their failed and irresponsible lending practices. To do so, they provided loans to Greece, Portugal, Spain and others to be flowed-through to the lending institutions. The lenders took a bit of haircut but effectively got bailed out. Meanwhile, fiscal austerity measures were imposed as loan conditions, on the heals of the GFC recession itself...thus driving these economies into depressions. In Greece, the decline in GDP has fallen further and for a longer period than during the 1930s Great Depression in the United States. (It took the opposite of austerity--protracted stimulus and then wartime spending--to get the U.S. out of those depths.)

Post-GFC Greek economy under EU austerity (Source: New York Times July 11)
Fiscal stimulus was used in Germany, France, the U.S. and elsewhere to recover from the GFC...It worked in Germany.

"Fiscal Stimulus in Germany in the Aftermath of the Great Recession" (Gyorgy Barabas 2013) Y-axis = billions GDP in Euros

Somehow finance ministries of certain countries find this to be an irresponsible option for Greece. Now they add a fire sale of national assets. What odds of recovery do London bookies give the latest scheme?

5. GREEK TRAGEDIES CAN ONLY BE AVOIDED THROUGH SYSTEMIC CHANGE...Moral hazard in the financial system has only been increased since the GFC. And it rests more with the system's creditors than with its debtors. That seems to be something much of the current northern European group of leaders still lacks the spine to address. They are more prepared to provide 'humanitarian assistance' for a deepening human crises on the continent than to muster this courage.

6. IS THE EUROPEAN POLITICAL PROJECT ITSELF NOW AT RISK? The last months' negotiations on the Greek debt crisis have evidenced increasing nationalistic sentiments, with classic utterances and tones of national-moral superiority, amongst both northern European political leaders and the populace. They are joined in self-righteousness by spokespeople from the finance industry. The hypocrisies and lapses in recent historical memory are breathtaking. What further tragedies remain in store?
Jeb Brugmann's latest book is

 Welcome to the Urban Revolution argues that the 21st century’s greatest challenges can—and must—be met through improved approaches to city building. Exploring the successes of cities like Barcelona, Chicago, Vancouver, and Brazil’s Curitiba, Brugmann shows how we can transform cities into more productive, equitable, and sustainable places. The most progressive cities, he reveals, have developed their own “practices of urbanism,” from the sidewalk up. These local urbanisms—ways of designing, governing, and living in cities that align competing interests behind common purposes—are what we need globally to guide an ever more urban civilization.


Popular posts from this blog

New Executive Director of UNEP announced

Erik Solheim according to Norwegian newspapers is to be announced today as the new Executive Director of UNEP. And later today Monday the 2nd of May ABC News confirm too.

He faced stiff competition for the number one job on the environment in the UN system. In the 6 Executive Directors of UNEP it will mean that developed countries will have had 5 of them with two Canadians (Strong and Dowdeswell) and Germany (Toepfer and Steiner). The only Executive Director to come from a developing country was Dr. Mostafa Kamal Tolba who died recently.

Erik brings considerable experience to the position having held been from 2007 to 2012  the combined portfolio of Norway’s Minister of the Environment and International Development; he also served as Minister of International Development from 2005 to 2007. During his time as minister Norwegian aid reached 1%, the highest in the world.

Since January 2013 he has been the Chair of the OECD Development Assistance Committee (DAC). In the DAC he has emphasi…

Guest Blog Mike Barry: 5 things we learnt on Marks and Spencer Plan A journey over last 12 months

Guest Blog by Mike Barry:  Director of Sustainable Business (Plan A) at Marks and Spencer

It’s that time of year, publication of our annual sustainability (Plan A) report. After the harum scarum dash to gather, collate, assure, sign-off and publish a wealth of data we can breathe (for a moment!) and reflect on what it all means.
Here are some quick insights into what we’ve learnt at M&S in the last 12 months on our Plan A journey.
1. Succession – Nine years is a long time in the world of sustainable business. How many corporate plans have come and gone since we launched Plan A in 2007? Too many! The continuity offered by having a single multi-year plan has been incredibly important. It’s allowed us to take long term decisions in a very short term turbulent retail marketplace. It’s allowed us to build the skills and capabilities in our business units to integrate Plan A into their ways of working. It’s allowed us to pick our battles, knowing that occasionally we’ve just got to let a …

Bokova out? Georgieva in for next UN Secretary General

The rumors that have been circulating for the last month have now proven to be true. The Bulgarian government has withdrawn support from Irina Bokova as their candidate for UN Secretary General and replaced her with Kristalina Georgieva, the European commissioner for budget and human resources.
There is some evidence that the right of center parties in European capitals have been behind this with some articles appearing in the last few weeks against Bokova. The Guardian reported on the 26th: “one of her (Kristalina’s) staff members was hacked and emails purporting to be from one of her top aides were sent out to the rest of her office, instructing them to attack Bokova”There is no question that Kristalina has the cv and record to be a very good UN Secretary General. She is a strong supporter of sustainable development issues she will pick up the SDGs and climate agendas with ease. She is dynamic and very personable and was very active around last week’s UN General Assembly High Level se…